marking scheme and course policies:
Communications policy: all research-related communication (final project proposals, monthly updates, final report, etc.) should be sent to your advisor and the instructor in the same email, so that we can ensure that everyone is`on the same page'.
AST1501 Marking: The final mark is 50% course and 50% research. The detailed percentages listed below refer to the course portion of the mark.
Note: if you write a first-author paper on your project and it is accepted by a refereed journal by one year after grades are due for the course (roughly May 2019), your final mark will be bumped upward (A- to A, A to A+). To qualify your advisor must attest that the paper is truly a first-author effort, i.e. that you took the lead on the work and its writeup.
COURSE Expectations and GRADING ELEMENTs
All enrolled students are expected to
1. Attend and participate in research presentations by faculty members and other class meetings (10% of course portion incl. participation)
2. Find an advisor and a project by the specified deadline
(see Timelines tab)
- Projects should be
feasible and interesting, clearly defined, and ultimately
publishable.
- Discuss the project's
motivation and background with your advisor
- Agree on its goals and
timeline.
- Make a plan to meet on
a weekly basis with your advisor.
3. Deliver write-ups and talks related to your chosen
project: (20% -- 7% written proposal, 8%
presentation, 5% feedback)
- Written project proposals by the
specified deadline (see Timelines tab)
- 3-pages AASTeX
manuscript format
- clear
& compelling motivations, methods, timeline, and
references
- will be
shared with peers
- Give feedback on your peers'
project proposals by the specified deadline.
- Revise your proposal,
accounting for feedback, by the specified deadline; e-mail
to Kristen and your advisor
- In-class presentations of the
project proposal
- Monthly progress updates (10%: 2-3
paragraphs, via email, to me and your advisor due end of
each month, starting December)
- Mid-course presentations (15%: 10 min +
discussion, dates specified under Timelines tab)
- Final write-up (15%:
ApJ Letter length in two-column AASTeX format ,
*or* draft
of paper for submission, within specified deadlines)
- Final project presentations (15%: 15
minutes + question period).
Note on final presentations: you and your advisor are
responsible for finding an external faculty member who can
evaluate the presentation. After the presentation we will
hold a "mini-defence" on the project, so you have the chance
to demonstrate your mastery of the subject and get a glimpse
of what the thesis qualifying exams will be like.
4. Participate in our discussions and activities to
promote good research habits and scientific expression
techniques
- Class meetings, e.g.
on presentation technique, science writing, figures and
posters, etc.
- Provide friendly and
constructive feedback to your peers, especially on their
project proposals and presentations
5. Take part in essential aspects of the scientific life
of the Department (15%) by
- Attending weekly colloquia
- Attending Department and CITA seminars as appropriate
- Attending at least one more science-related event per
week, such as:
- astro-ph coffee
(preprint discussion)
- CITA seminars
- CITA blackboard
seminars
- Group discussions:
dynamics, cosmology, star & planet formation, fluids,
high-energy/gravity, etc.
- Talking to people outside your
immediate area of research: attending CITA dessert, joining
colloquium speakers for dinner, etc.
Finally of course,
6. Do a good job on the research project itself! (The entire 50% research half of the mark!)
So in conclusion ...
It is essential to fully engage with these various
activities, even if you already have a research project
underway and feel you know what you're up to.
You may find useful supporting information on the webpage Resources
for Young Researchers web page, where Chris Matzner
has been keeping tips and advice for young graduate
students.